Buccaneers QB Situation: Baker, Jalon, or Too Early to Tell?

0

With the Tampa Bay Buccaneers’’ first victory of this quickly-moving 2026 season, there have been plenty of overreactions. 

“Jalon Daniels is the future!” “Zac Robinson is actually a good offensive coordinator!” “Todd Bowles should keep his job!”

The Future?

Ok, maybe that last one is a phrase no one has uttered all season, and the second is just as much of an overreaction as the first, but that first claim is the most interesting. 

Daniels struggled in his first career start in the NFL, as the Bucs fell to the Green Bay Packers last Sunday after Baker Mayfield injured his thumb in the Bucs’ previous game, sidelining him for at least 3 weeks. 

He threw a pair of picks, was sacked 3 times, and put up a very pedestrian 5.5 yards per attempt. 

Primetime Rebound 

But Daniels came out looking like a confident, competent quarterback Thursday night against a bad Dallas Cowboys defense. He ended up with a very respectable 76% completion rate, with 189 yards and no interceptions. 

Daniels benefited greatly from a dynamite rushing attack, as the Bucs ran for 241 yards as a team. Star back Bucky Irving had himself quite a night, with 165 yards on the ground and an eye-popping 7.9 yards per carry on 21 attempts. 

Defense Shined

Even the Bucs’ defense had a heck of a game, with 2 interceptions and limiting an explosive Cowboys offense to only a pair of touchdowns. 

The special teams got in on the fun, too, with a recovered fumble on a kickoff. 

So, all of this to say, this was a super high-level performance for the team. It would’ve taken a truly putrid performance from the quarterback spot to screw this game up and submit a loss. 

Great Story But…

This was not a game to take away any grand evaluations of Daniels as an NFL QB, but it certainly makes for a wonderful story. 

Undrafted guy, his mom was there giving heartfelt interviews, it’s all awesome, and it being the start of a marvelous career would be one of those storybook things fans dream about for their team. 

Is counting on that being the future enough to make any decisions about benching the recently extended Mayfield in favor of Daniels? Maybe, but probably not. 

55 Million Problems 

Even if Daniels goes out next Sunday against the Steelers and balls out, leading the Bucs to their second victory of the season, there’s about 55 million reasons for the Bucs to stick with Mayfield when he’s cleared to return. 

The awkwardness of the situation would remind some folks of another former Bucs QB’s entry into the NFL, as Tom Brady had something similar happen with veteran Drew Bledsoe. 

Daniels is unlikely to be Brady, and Mayfield isn’t Bledsoe, so the comparison is a bit tough, but Daniels could continue to play at a high level and make things very uncomfortable. 

What would it take for Daniels to be named the starter for the rest of the season? A few things:

  • Baker’s injury would have to keep him out longer than the 3 weeks from initial reports on his thumb, an unlikely occurrence for a tough guy like Mayfield. 
  • Daniels would have to not only play really well, the Bucs would probably have to be undefeated over that span. Long shot for a team that’s played as poorly as the Bucs. 
  • And, this is super important, Baker Mayfield would have to be a good sport about it; the good news is this seems like the least of the troubles. Mayfield was excited on the sideline Thursday night, cheering on Daniels and the team. It doesn’t hurt that Mayfield’s already been paid. Of course, who knows how that tune might change if the former Jayhawks is taking the reins full-time.   

Win-Win

The good news is the Buccaneers can also try to pitch this to Mayfield as a win-win in terms of Mayfield missing a bit more time than he probably wants. They give the former first overall pick some extra time for his thumb, and they get more playing time to decide the future of the Bucs under center, this season and beyond. 

There is that secret third option for the Bucs and their QB situation beyond this season, where they look elsewhere for help, through the draft or a trade. 

But for now, it’s fun that the Bucs beat the Cowboys, and if Daniels makes this a really difficult situation, that means the Bucs are winning and maybe even won the lottery in the quarterback room, with an UDFA as their potential franchise guy. 

You add in the worst division in football, with the division led by a pair of very shaky 2-2 teams, and the Bucs might not be quite dead this season. 

Only nearly dead. 

Follow @ctbrantley12 on Twitter and listen to him on the RBLR Bucs Podcast

Follow, Like and Subscribe to Bucs Report

BucsReport.com

BucsReport.com

For more on this and everything Buccaneers check back here hourly at BucsReport.com.

 

Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmail